Mafia 2 vs L.A. Noire

apple or pear?

both but L.A Noire is better

LA Noire it's deep, good looking and a nice game to play. Way better than Mafia (played both of them)

Mafia 2

Mafia 1 much better them both

Both are good games!

Mafia 2 is really nice but it's way too short, and by that i mean extremely. But it was a great experience playing the game. And it has a good storyline.
L.A. Noire is more like a movie than a game. But the world is large and there's a lot to explore.
Hope i helped you a bit with this info :p
why don't you just buy both of them? :O

Mafia 2 all the way!
So good game I will buy it from christmas sale because I don't have steam version...

well , both are among my favorite games . both are amazingly nice . I wonder why ''L.A. Noir'' got so many negative reviews :/